[Tip for Educators] Designing Rubrics for Assessment


Learning is measured to estimate and minimize the gap between ‘learned’ and ‘not learned’. 

This gap is what determines the learner performance and defines success among them. To understand and develop such capacities, it is important to define and create valid rubrics for assessments. Assessments without rubrics is just like travel without destination.   Rubrics are as important as the assessments. Designing rubrics requires a complete preview to the learning outcomes. This article is an insight into how such rubrics can be developed for any type of assessments.

To begin with it is important to identify the types of assessment methods.  Generally they can be classified to

  •         Oral
  •         Written
  •         Technical
  •         Creative

The assessment guidelines are statements which allows probing into the assessment outcomes. 

No.

Assessment type

Assessment guidelines for building rubrics

1

Talk shows – Debates, discussions, JAMs, Mock works, Drama, Role-plays, etc.,

  1.       What do you expect from the topic?
  2.       Does it require learner presentation appropriately?
  3.       Does it require behaviour presentation?
  4.       Does it require emotional control
  5.       Does it require ethical view?

2

Written – Compositions, Letters, Dialogues, Articles, Projects, Research work etc.,

  1.       What are the guidelines for writing?
  2.       What type of writing is preferred?
  3.       What ideas do you expect in the writing?
  4.       How to check plagiarism?
  5.       What skill emphasis need to be laid down?

3

Creative – Collage, poetry, Slogan writing, Critical reviews, Cartooning, painting, music etc.,

  1.       Relevancy to the topic in hand.
  2.       Appropriate use of words or colours
  3.       Message promoted
  4.       Check on plagiarism
  5.       Uniqueness of the work

4

Technical – LMS, Apps, Presentations, Online works, Collaboration, Social media works etc.,

  1.       Type of work allocated
  2.       Type of performance level expected
  3.       Setting as per the technology opted
  4.       Competency development
  5.       Behaviour online

 

The guidelines are characteristics on what is the larger idea for the work that is incorporated into the assessments.  Once this is designed, it is important for the next level of setting, which is relevant for the subject and topic under consideration.  Rubric designs are based on the assessment specifications which can be based on four major categories of grading.  Grading preferably can be 4 - 6 for a better understanding of performance.  More the number of grades, specifics and overlaps are prominent and less number of grades categorisation becomes difficult.

Type

Marks

Grade

Specifications(minimum 5 – 6 to be provided in the rubrics design)

NA

0

E

Not attempted or no productive work done

Fair

1

D

Complied to any one of the specifications

Average

2

C

Complied to any two of the specifications

Good

3

B

Complied to any three of the specifications

Excellent

4

A

Complied to 4 or above as per the specifications

Rubric designing depends on the work done and the subject for which the said is constructed.  The flow of the content must have definite citations for further work and analysis.  The major flow of subject can be designed as follows to stream line the specifics for the rubrics.  All assessments need not carry rubrics.  The assessment designed with rubrics ensures the outcomes with criteria for analysis.

rubric-for-assessment

Design of Rubrics is mainly subject and task based.

https://www.teachingchannel.org/videos/designing-rubrics

Rubrics should finally give the total picture on gradations of student performance.  Some of the basic guidelines for design of rubrics can be obtained from the Carnegie Mellon University website.  The rubrics built should encompass the totality of the work done, step wise procedures that needs to be done for the given task, and the process through which the outcome has been achieved.  The basic format for design of such rubrics can be done as follows.

designing-rubrics-for-assessment

The learning outcome and possible feedback relies upon the rubric design.  It is observable that without the right design of rubrics, analysis and feedback becomes controversial.  Without the right feedback, learner growth and performance becomes a large question.  Aim to achieve the learning and learning gap is what we need to focus while developing rubrics.  Assessments for and of learning enhances and brings out the best when directed towards better outcomes.

About the Author
I work as Academic Coordinator at Nalanda Educational Institutions, Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh. Worked in implementing Technology supportive curriculum in our organisation. Trainer and Curriculum designer for technology based Curriculum.

Like what we do?

The Latest EdTech News To Your Inbox

Follow us:

   

   

 

Latest EdTech News To Your Inbox

 

The EdTech Tweets

EdTechReview Can Voice User Interfaces Be The New Teaching-Learning Assistants? - EdTechReview https://t.co/pPMKBwwYOa… https://t.co/U2ZZnjg4Lg
About 6 hours ago
EdTechReview Learning Games & Activities for Toddlers, Below are few games and activities that you will find useful to teach the… https://t.co/5bhfcL3ZlQ
About 9 hours ago

Follow etr_in on Twitter

About ETR Community

EdTechReview (ETR) is a community of and for everyone involved in education technology to connect and collaborate both online and offline to discover, learn, utilize and share about the best ways technology can improve learning, teaching, and leading in the 21st century.

EdTechReview spreads awareness on education technology and its role in 21st century education through best research and practices of using technology in education, and by facilitating events, training, professional development, and consultation in its adoption and implementation.

 

-> Read More

Join The Community

Subscribe and Join the 55,000+ members who trust us...

Testimonials
I find every news, reviews very informative and interesting. This site is indeed a great site for both teachers and learners. Thanks to EdTech for creating such an enriching site on education. Hats off!!
- Regin Brown, Educationist and Blogger, United Kingdom


My group likes this site because it's so up-to-date and has tons of relevant articles.
- Angela Giuliano, Teacher, New Mexico


Your write ups and articles ignites the minds making them receptive to the whole new wealth of EdTech.
- Jagat Rana, Parent, India


EdTechReview has some great resources for teachers who need to get some ideas about technology in the classroom.
- Loretta Wideman,Teacher, East Africa


EdTechReview keeps educators up to date with trending tech savvy terms relative to the discipline.
- Dr. Ingrid Rizzolo,Education Professional, Curriculum and Instruction Designer, New York City Area

-> Read More

Go to Our Client List

Adobe Avaya Bettasia Bonio Campus Management CK12 CKS Evernote IBM Intel IQPC Kidzania McGraw Hill Moodle Moot USC Rossier CMR University The British School Canadian International School Pathways Ridge Valley

Subscribe to our Newsletters...